Should I consent to my 11 year feeble enjoy a phone?
I feel that it's not a dutiful idea to give a child that young a cell phone because it's freshly another way for them to grow up too fast. We might have great kids (I know my kids are great) but they shouldn't be going anywhere where on earth there might not be either another adult or some benign of access to a phone. This is a responsibility that you don't need until you are old enough to hold down a livelihood and pay for it yourself. My kids won't get one until they can drive.
well ur not crazy ill tell you that take no notice of the ppl saying ur crazy i know 8 or 7 years olds with cell phones and they dont even use them for emergincies they use them for watever they please and that is crazy but an 11 year older using one for emergincies is not maybe you could get her one of those phones where u can only just put 4 numbers in like so she can call mom dad grandma or 911 or something later she wont waste money on texting friends when shes really not old enough for that however but for emergincies yes get her one and maybe when shes 12 or 13 maybe 14 u can receive her a phone for things like texting and calling her friends she may start begging you for one sooner though trust mee im 13 and i have not agree to it go my mom hears it every hour Source(s): mee
I say get her a free one that comes beside the addition of another line. No texting though, she should show she is responsible then bring back the texting for her birthday if that's what she wants.
just went thought this myself. I have a 9 and 10 yr prehistoric daughters. Do they NEED a phone? NO. They are usually with me or just outside my door. But it is something they REALLY, REALLY wanted. I am not a mother that indulges - BUT - my kids studied so unyielding in school this year. They both got unflawed scores at the end of the year state testing. The both qualified for the National Scripps Spelling Bee on the arts school level and placed. They both won medals for a national word analogy contest. My youngest was standard into the gifted students program. I figure since they work so hard, do lots of chores and do them responsibly and never really ask for much - I said what the heck. They own had them for about a month. They love them. We have terrifically strict rules - no texting - and the first time they misplace/abuse privileges - the phones are gone. So far, no problems. Sometimes, if a child is deserving - you have to throw them a bone.
I'm 11 and I'm getting a phone tomorrow. Because my parents trust me and believe that I have to hold a way to communicate with them and my friends and they're going to make sure I enjoy their number my sisters number & my grandma's number in case of an emergency so you should get her one because if she does she will not bring advantage of it yet to get her a plan beside free minutes after like 5 or something like that like on weekends so when she's gone she can ring up you without running up minutes and let's face it every kid is gonna find a way to bargain to their friends Source(s): :-)
Times are different. I think as soon as a child starts going out with friends or to the park by themselves, going for walks down the street to the neighbors afterwards its time for a phone. But it should be limited to emergencys. I know they have plans where it can be similar to the phone can only call home mom or dad cell and 911 . I think explicitly a good idea for any child who can dial to have a phone because the world is only weird anymore and you never know. But i would say if its going to be for texting/ chatting with friends... NO GOOD a moment ago will be distracting for a kid that age Best of luck with your decision :)
It depends.
I got a phone when I be 12 because I needed to it call my mom to pick me up from various school/extracurricular events. It was a well brought-up thing for me to have.
this is the pre teen age...and when the kids get to be that age they start becoming heavily influenced by respectively other and older teens. im not saying that because everyone else has one, that your kiddo should. what if they be with their friends and something bad happened? they will more than promising call you. make some rules...
1. when you call them...they will answer, no if's and's or but's give or take a few it.
2. they will pull their own weight in the responsibility of owning a phone. housework or sward work might be an option as a sort of payment...because nothing is free. (teaches a honest lesson and responsibility)
if they do not follow these rules let them know that it will be taken away from them and it will not be given back. be strict about it and if your foot have to be put down..keep it firmly planted. =]
yes let her have a phone but explain she is only to use it for emergency.
I got my first phone at that age and it was fine for me. i would articulate yes for his birthday or christmas but get a basic pay and you step phone, not one that does pictures and videos and all sorts of stuff. calling the emergency services is free even without credit. but I don`t know you could put a fiver on his phone every now and again so he can text people but if he is silly beside his credit don't put money on again.
Don't get your daughter her own phone that'ss too young.
Instead buy a cheap pay as you progress phone and give it to her when she will be spending the night a friends, going some place alone and so forth. That way she'll own it in case of a true emergency.
I reflect on it is unecessary.. I got a phone when I was like 16 and I go amiss to see why ur kid wud need it at 11. You shud give a phone to the kid whenver she goes out to stuff..that passageway she can call u and u know she is safe.
If u do want to buy her a phone-buy one without camera..so she doen't click photos andstuff. But I do not conjecture something really awful will happen to her if she gets a phone soon- I mean, eveything within a phone is already in the PC.
It depends on the situation. If she has avalid reason, apart from "adjectives my friends have it" then she shud have it. Otherwise it is unecessary!
Tc..
I am eleven and my parents gave mee a phone because i am never home. I think they can trust me and i will appointment with emergencies but i also use it to talk to my friends. They get me unlimeted texting and 300 minutes per month. Maybe you could do something like that. And if i want a nicer phone or more minutes i have to pay for it myself. :(
it depends on how she does contained by school, and how she actsa at home. My parents gave it to me also becasue i made straight A;s last year. :):) look at things similar to that.
Yes, if she is involved contained by events, a cell phone would be a good investment for emergency use. Source(s): But don't get a plan phone. They aren't necessary for her age. Get similar to a TracFone, Go Phone, or a Virgin Mobile. Just a simple Pay-As-You-Go phone is fine.
Answers: 11 is way too young in my feelings. But I do see where you're coming from. My older sister bought her daughter a phone when she was 11/12 and she is immediately 14. It has been hell on the family. That piece is connected to her arm. No matter how good then intentions would be or how great your daughter is, it will other be a huge temptation for her to be like older kids.
If It be my kid and I wanted to try it our for a while, or think she needed one for emergencies or to give the name me or her dad I would get her this.
http://www.fireflymobile.com/
they are really cool for younger kid and you get to program in the numbers, within is no direct dialing. So, you, dad, 911,maybe grandparents and a friend/friends mom?
A good trial and it will help her to swot up responsibility.
Hi! i am 11 and i have a phone. i belive 11 12 or 10 is a worthy year for a phone. the phone you choose shouldn't be very flashy. somthing that she could drop and doesn't break. i hope i helped. (plus getting her a phone i bet would take some nagging rotten your back ( : ~Polka
If she is responsible and will take care of it, sure. I bet general public are making a big deal out of this, but there's no good reason why she's not matured enough.
If they go out a lot, after yes. It depends what they want it for. If they only want it to talk to friends then perchance you should wait a while.
I would if she go places with out you. Mine got one at 10 because she was on time off out of state with her dad. he is bad about not answering his phone. She's 12 in a minute and just got a new, nice one. Her other be a $10 phone added to our plan. Don't waste a lot of money until you see how she does with it.
Yeah shure why not. If Your worried about them doing stuff just get a phone next to a camera. Or you could get a go phone.
Let her enjoy one. I know 9 year olds with phones.
<-------- Still doesn't have a phone
rephrase the question. A existence threatening emergency happens nearby your kid. Should they have a phone?
Yeah, she sounds responsible. Maybe get her a Tracfone. You don't have to pay packet the cell phone company every month. You prepay for all the minutes and if you use all the minutes, you can't talk anymore until you make the addition of minutes. So it will give you some control of how long she can talk. I got a Tracfone when I be 12 and its great for emergencies.
ya it gives them another opening to communicate and talk to his/her friends outside of schools... also it brings him/her more friends becuz he/her can talk to more ppl out of institution
Sure, let her have one. But run over with her that when you call, she must pick up, even if she is talking to an historic friend.
Yes,
especially if they are active in sports or in covering of emergencies.
Get her a TracFone ( http://www.tracfone.com/ ) and limit her use on it. Only let her have it when she's next to her friends, or at said church events, and things like that. Do not let her have it during academy, around the house, or when she's out with you. She doesn't need a phone then.
I'm 14 and i dont think my dad trusts me, he also believes they cause cancer XD
Related Questions:
